[Home]
Growing organic black
beans in Veneta, Oregon
(17 miles west of Eugene, Southern Willamette Valley, Western Oregon) October, 2009b
Allen Dong, I-Tech, PO Box 413, Veneta, OR 97487, USA
www.efn.org/~itech/
Public domain, no copyright --a gift to humanity
- planting
date: May 1-31, (typically May 12-20). Early plantings have
longer growing season, potentially higher yield, less irrigation
required, more weeds and greater risk of spring frost damage.
Late plantings allow more weeds to emerge and be tilled prior to
planting, but shorter growing season.
- crop rotation:
- summer bean > winter cover crop > summer
bean > winter cover crop = bean year after year, with a winter cover
crop to break the disease cycle. The cover crop can not be beans
but vetch, fava and peas are acceptable (Steve Temple, UC Davis extension
agronomist, personal communication). Six consecutive years of
summer beans and winter cover crop, followed by fallow, wheat and 4
consecutive years of summer beans and winter cover crop showed no buildup
of diseases in Veneta.
- A possible rotation of 4 or 5 years of bean followed
by wheat; repeat 4 or 5 years of bean followed by wheat. A shorter rotation
of bean, wheat, bean, wheat, does not work very well. Weeds
(mustard, radish) mature and shatter in the wheat stand before wheat is
harvested, resulting in higher weed population in the following bean
crop. Also, wheat with no fertilizer input, grown on a 6
consecutive year bean field has higher yield and heavier test-weight
(density) than grown on a short year cycle of bean>wheat>bean>wheat.
- overseeding
bean with a winter cover crop on the last cultivation in late July
allows early establishment of cover crop. Cover crops of clover
(alsike, crimson, Persian, red and yellow), fava, vetch and wheat were
established and grew to 4-12 inches tall at harvest time (September
15). The cover crops did not interfere with bean harvest when
combined directly off the plant; but the cover crop may interfere if
bean plants are knifed, windrowed then combined. Overseeding with
fava resulted in a poor stand because the large seeds were not
adequately planted into the soil during the last cultivation.
Overseeding with winter wheat resulted in a poor wheat stand, possible
reasons are rodents and birds ate the wheat seeds or unfavorable
condition to germinate wheat in July.
- Fertilizer input: lime, potassium, phosphorus, sulfur and
boron. Suspected boron deficiency symptoms were observed (Figure 1
and 2). "Root growth greatly retarded with dark colored, corky
areas" (Pscheidt, J W, Ocamb, CM. 2008 Pacific Northwest Plant Disease Management
Handbook, Key to Nutrient Deficiencies in
Vegetable Crops). As a consequence of poor root development, lack of
secondary roots and absence of rhizobia inoculation, boron deficiency
appears as yellowing of older leaves (similar to nitrogen deficiency) or
irregular shaped leaves with wide midribs (similar to boron deficiency on
apple).
- Major weeds encountered at Veneta:
- nightshades (Solonaceae solanum) : nightshade
berries interfere with post harvest seed cleaning; berry size and density are similar
to black bean, until the berries dry, then they winnow out easily.
Wet nightshade berries take 2+ months to air-dry. Nightshade plant
emerges in June- July; can be removed with flex tine cultivator, until
~July 1 when the flex tine cultivator damages 6-10 inches tall bean
plants. The flex tine cultivator will suppress nightshade weeds but
does not completely eliminate it.
- wild mustard and radish (Brassicaceae Brassica
and Raphanus) : the 1-2 inch thick radish head can jamb the combine
draper belt/ feed system; wet seed pods are difficult to winnow during
the post harvest seed cleaning process but small, dryer pods (5-15 days of air drying)
winnow out readily. Wet pods can rot in the drying bin and
contaminate adjacent beans. Wild mustard and radish emerges through
out the growing season, from March to September. They are
controlled but not eliminated with flex tine cultivator in conjunction
with rotary hoe and sweeps, especially during the early part of the
growing season (May – July 10). Later emerging mustards and
radishes will not develop mature seeds when beans are harvested, thus
will not produce a weed crop for the next year.
- wild buckwheat (Polygonaceae Polygonum): the
vines tangle with the bean plant and interfere with combining. Flex tine
cultivator and rotary hoe remove young shallow rooted weeds, but do not
remove well rooted weeds.
- smart weed (Polygonaceae Polygonum) : compete
for nutrient, light and water. It is removed with flex tine
cultivator in conjunction with rotary hoe; rotary hoe is more
effective.
- lambs
quarter (Chenopodiaceae Chenopodium) competes for sunlight and
nutrient. Small amount of lambs quarter is beneficial when direct
combining beans off the plant (not knifed and winnrowed before
combining); it provide physical support for beans that otherwise would
lodge; lodging increases with each rain at harvest time.
- Canada thistle (Asteraceae Cirsium) tough
perennial competitor; no means of control by mechanical cultivation
(yet?)
- Weed control: flex tine cultivator, Figure 4 (design available at
http://efn.org/~itech/),
rotary hoe (Figure 5) and sweeps (Figure 6) are synergistic. The
flex tine cultivator and rotary hoe remove weeds in the plant row and
between the plant row when bean plants are short, <6 inches.
Sweeps remove everything in its path but can not be used in the plant
row. Mechanical cultivation is more effective in sunny and windy
conditions. Variations of the following mechanical cultivation
procedure were used on 14 acres of black beans for 5 years, 2005 to
2009, and successfully suppressed weeds, but not a complete
elimination.
- First cultivation: pre emergence cultivation
with flex tines; 1-2 passes at 6 mph ground speed, 2-5 days after planting
(bean emerges 7-14 days after planting, depending on weather). The
flex tine cultivator scratches the surface creating channels ~3/4 to 1
inch deep and removes weeds at the white root stage in direct path of the
tines (blind cultivation, weed have not yet emerged above the soil
surface).
- Post
emergence cultivation: rotary hoe 4-6 days after bean plant emergence,
1 or 2 passes on the same day; ground speed 8-12 mph. The rotary
hoe creates pits ~1 ½ inches deep, 2 ½ x 3 ½ inch spacing. This
lifts shallow rooted weeds, breaks the soil-water capillary
conductivity, desiccates shallow rooted weeds including those not
lifted out of the soil and disrupts the channels created by the flex
tine cultivator. The rotary hoe penetrates deeper but has less
coverage of the soil surface, compared to the flex tine
cultivator.
- Second post emergence cultivation: flex tine
4-8 days after rotary hoe disrupt the channels created by prior flex
tine pass.
- Subsequent cultivations, alternate between flex
tine, rotary hoe and sweeps
- Last rotary hoe cultivation, 4 inch tall beans
~June 10 at ~6 mph ground speed; last flex tine cultivation, 8 inch tall
beans ~July 1 at ~3 mph ground speed; last sweep cultivation, ~85%
canopy in late July - August 1.
- Alternative (and less effective) cultivation
procedure using flex tine and sweeps; without using a rotary hoe.
Reconfigure the flex tine cultivator so that the tine positions (and the
channels on the soil surface created by the tines) are
asymmetrical. In Figure 5 shown below, the flex tine cultivator has
two 5 feet wide sections; tines are spaced 8 inches apart in both
sections. In an asymmetrical cultivator, the tine spacing on one of
the section is 8 inches apart; and a 7½ inch spacing
on the other section. The spacing of soil surface channels created
by the section with 8 inch tine spacing will be different from the
spacing of channels created by the section with 7½ inch tine spacing.
Drive the cultivator in both directions so that channels created by 8
inch tine spacing will disrupt channels created by 7½ inch tine
spacing when driven in the 180 degrees opposite direction.
- Irrigation: first irrigation is in late June; no irrigation needed
to germinate beans.
- Harvest:
Allis Chalmers All-Crop combine can harvest the beans directly off the
plants, without knifing and windrowing the beans prior to
combining. To minimize bean splits during combining, reduce the
combine cylinder speed (~400-500 rpm) and use 1 concave bar (remove the
second concave bar). Beans have indeterminate flowering, some
pods are ready to harvest while late flowering pods are green.
Depending on weather, there is a 10-20% loss from lodging, pod
shattering, bean splits; additional loss from inclement weather.
- Weather (rain) is a limiting factor in growing dry beans in western
Oregon; affecting planting, early weed control, harvest and post harvest
drying. Mature bean pods can tolerate 4-8 days of light rain; however
the plant sags lower to the ground, making it difficult to harvest,
increases diseases as well as weed re-growth. It almost always rain
at least once during a 10 day harvest period in Veneta,
Oregon. Equipments must be in good condition, ready to go and
be ready to dodge the rain. Preventative maintenance is better than
emergency repair; if it is not broken, fix it anyway.
- Post harvest drying. It almost always rain at least once
during post harvest drying. Assume that fog will form at night during
part of the drying period. Moisture condensation on beans in
the drying bins (Figure 6 and 7) can occur if the blower circulates cold
nighttime air, chills the bean temperature down then blow warm daytime
humid air on cold beans. Wet beans and weeds will mold.
Use an electric timer to switch off cold air circulating through the drying bin at night during high humidity conditions.
- Seed
cleaning: Screens are a 21/64 inch diameter round hole at the top
to remove large pods and dirt; an intermediate screen with 12/64 x ¾
inch slotted (oval) holes; bottom screen is 10/64 x ¾ inch slotted
(oval) holes to remove split beans, small stems etc. Beans are
winnowed following screen cleaning (electric winnower design available
at http://efn.org/~itech/ ). Winnowing will remove some split beans, but the slotted screen is more effective.
- Black beans will cross pollinate with pinto, kidney and other
common beans (Ashworth, S 1991. Seed to Seed. Seed Savers Exchange,
Decorah, Iowa). Experience from Veneta: seeds from cross pollinated
black and pinto bean produce black speckled beans with tan background
color; cross pollinated black and kidney bean is intermediate color, size
and shaped bean.
- Pinto
bean has higher yield because of its vine growth habit, but more
difficult to harvest directly off the vine (not a problem if bean
plants are knifed and windrowed before combining). Kidney bean is
easier to clean because its large size is significantly different from
weed seeds and pods. Dark colored beans (black, pinto) hide
cosmetic blemishes better than light colored beans; not a problem if
beans are polished to remove blemishes. Soybean is the easier to
grow because its strong upright stalk will support pods off the ground
and shed rain better than common beans.
Suspected boron deficiency

Figure 1. Left: Healthy bean roots, white internal flesh and secondary
root growth. Right: suspected boron deficiency: internal brown cork and
lack secondary root growth.

Figure 2. Close up of suspected boron deficient roots. Roots are sliced open to show internal brown corks and lesions.
Mechanical cultivators
Figure 3. Flex tine cultivator

Figure 4. Rotary hoe

Figure 5. Sweeps and mini disks
Post harvest drying

Figure 6. Grain drying bins, made from 4ft x 4 ft totes, connected to a
blower.

Figure 7. Top view of a grain drying bin, showing poly shade cloth (partly
removed), 1 x 1 inch wire mesh screen, 2 x 2 inch wood support for wire screen
and sheet metal air diffuser.